Superior Vision covers contact lenses on a smaller allowance than most of its competitors, but it does one thing better than EyeMed and it defines the fitting in a way that catches new wearers out.
The definition is the part worth reading twice.
The numbers
From a published Superior Vision benefit summary:
- Elective contact lens allowance — $100 in network, one per calendar year
- Out of network — reimbursed up to $100
- Fitting copay — $35, standard or specialty, once per calendar year
- Balance over the allowance — 20% off for conventional lenses, 10% off for disposables
- Contacts are in lieu of the eyeglass lenses and frame benefit
Two things stand out immediately.
$100 is low. VSP and EyeMed commonly run $150, Davis runs $125 off-Collection. If you are comparing plans at open enrolment, Superior’s contact lens allowance is at the bottom of the range.
But disposables actually get a discount here. Ten percent off the balance is not much — on a $500 balance it is $50 — but EyeMed gives disposable wearers nothing at all. Since the large majority of wearers are in disposables, that comparison matters more than the headline allowance suggests. A $100 allowance plus 10% of the balance can land close to a $150 allowance plus nothing.
The definition that catches new wearers
Superior splits the fitting into standard and specialty, and the dividing line is not what you would guess:
“Standard contact lens fitting applies to a current contact lens user who wears disposable, daily wear, or extended wear lenses only. Specialty contact lens fitting applies to new contact wearers and/or a member who wear toric, gas permeable, or multi-focal lenses.”
Read that again. Being new to contact lenses makes you a specialty fit — even if you are being fitted in the most ordinary spherical daily disposable on the market.
That is not unreasonable clinically. A first fit involves teaching insertion and removal, checking the lens on the eye, and follow-up that an experienced wearer does not need. It genuinely takes longer. But it is not how most people would read the word “specialty”, and it changes what the plan pays:
- Standard fitting — covered in full after the $35 copay
- Specialty fitting — a $100 allowance, not covered in full
So an experienced wearer pays $35 and is done. A first-time wearer pays $35 and then whatever the fitting costs above $100.
Anyone in toric, gas permeable or multifocal lenses lands in the same bracket permanently.
What this means in practice
If you are being fitted for the first time, ask what the fitting will cost before it starts. You are a specialty fit under this plan whether or not anyone says the word, and the $100 allowance may not cover it. This is a fair question and the front desk will know the number.
If you wear toric or multifocal lenses, budget for the same. It is not a penalty — those fittings genuinely take more chair time — but it should not be a surprise on the invoice.
If you are an established wearer in a plain disposable, Superior treats you well on the fitting: $35, covered in full, once a year.
Stacking it
With a $100 allowance, the other savings matter more here than on a richer plan. All three of these are separate from your benefit and from each other:
- Buy an annual supply and claim the manufacturer rebate. On many lenses the rebate is larger than Superior’s entire allowance.
- Pay the balance with FSA or HSA money — 22 to 37 percent off whatever is left, depending on your bracket.
- Check whether you qualify as medically necessary. If you do, the allowance stops being the relevant number entirely.
And compare the actual lens price before you commit — our price index tracks what the same boxes cost across retailers, and that spread is often wider than the difference between two carriers’ allowances.
Plan terms vary by employer group. The figures above are from one published Superior Vision benefit summary and are not universal; check your own certificate of coverage. Reviewed by Dr. Teresita Bollar, OD.
